This post in my catching-up-on-reviews series was supposed to be called “Five Star Fantasy Reads.” Great title, right? Short, sweet, to the point. If only. As it turns out, the fantasy genre is *a bit trickier* than that. If you care to read on, I will explain. {Or you can scroll down to the reviews…no judgment from me!}
The Preamble
Let’s visit a bookstore, shall we? When you walk into a bookstore today, up front you will see three main displays.
The first display will have cover upon cover showing women walking away or gazing into the distance. Or possibly there will just be a seascape on the cover. This is the historical fiction display, a medium-ish table of books.
The second display will all have stickers with celebrities’ names on them who have claimed these titles for their book clubs. It’s like The Voice for books. Team Reese or Team Oprah! Team Jenna is having a good season. This is a fairly narrow selection of literary fiction for people who buy books they intend to read someday, perhaps on a flight or on vacation.
But the biggest display at the front of the bookstore will have covers showing all manner of silver swords and flowers, swirling fonts, maybe a gorgeous dress, and definitely some sort of feather – a wing, a quill, something like that. The edges of the display table will be adorned with special edition board games and impractical mugs. This is the fantasy genre. And it is a having a moment. Gone are the days when The Lord of the Rings and The Chronicles of Narnia were the only widely popular series in fantasy (though inarguably still the best, the-end-and-thank-you). Gone also are the days when small but scarily thick fantasy paperbacks with questionable cover art took up a small back corner of bookstores where only the nerdiest and bravest readers dared to go. The success of Harry Potter and The Game of Thrones has gradually but undeniably exploded the fantasy genre from obscurity to the front window display.
And why not? Castles, capes, magical abilities, fantastic beings, heroes and conflicts and spells…it is all highly imaginative, whimsical, captivating…everything a book lover reading for escapism or pleasure could hope for. In theory, I am all for it. The fantasy genre takes readers back to what reading was like when we were kids, when suspending belief in favor of a new world and a good story was easy and all-consuming.
And the potential this genre has for allegory or story telling that ultimately has a bedrock in truth and goodness? The sky is not even the limit.
And yet.
There are few fantasy books I can get in and out of cover-to-cover without finding at least one or two facets that don’t sit well with me. Often, darkness hovers in the pages of many of these fantasy books marketed to teens and adults. As my teenagers and I have delved into the genre lately, we’ve been faced with badly skewed versions of healthy reality, especially when romance is involved, and a mixed up sense of good and evil. So, as I bring some book reviews to you today, I’d also like to give a caveat: when it comes to fantasy, gentle readers, proceed with caution. It’s wild, and there are no rules– authors can put whatever the heck they want into their worlds…so. Yeah. Caution. As a reader who is most at home in books written between 1900-1950, there are very few fantasy books that don’t cause me some discomfort. But I won’t give up on it as a whole, because when it is good, it is very, very good.
[Side note: I am happy to say the children’s fantasy genre still produces gem after gem. We discovered some great ones in 2025-26 that will be featured in the next post!]
To the books!
Book Reviews – Adult and Y.A. Fantasy Books
{For my very favorite, top of the list, 5 star fantasy reads of the last year, check out this New Favorite Authors post and read Elizabeth Lowham and Elisabeth Aimee Brown}



Tress of the Emerald Sea – Don’t try to read a blurb describing this book, just dive in! The humor and world building in this stand-alone novel by fantasy legend Brandon Sanderson is next level. There’s barely a character you can truly root against. Tress is a new favorite in my book world. 4.25 stars. Content caution: Recommend for high school and up due to language and some gore.
Once a Queen – This book was gentle and beautiful, with tones of George Macdonald’s The Princess and the Goblin but in a more modern setting. It is a light read, possibly a little disappointingly light for a reader deeply committed to fantasy books with lots of world building and plot twists, but it was lovely and I will definitely read the second and third books. 4 stars. Content caution: I would hand this to anyone middle school and up, and would easily call it “wholesome.”
The Seven-and-a-half Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle – I listened to the audiobook of this one, got really lost in the middle, and by 75% wanted to know the end but mainly just wanted it to all be over. It was the worst kind of Groundhog Day story BUT I still ended up enjoying the novelty of it and the setting of an early 1900s crumbling mansion and houseful of guests. I appreciated the talent of the narrator in doing so many different voices and giving them all weight in the story. The whole plot idea was super original; I did not guess the end at all. However, I would have gotten through it a lot faster and a lot less scathed if I could’ve skimmed over some of the many, many violent parts by reading the hard copy instead. 3.75 stars. Content caution: heavy violence and the typical mature themes of murder mysteries.


What the River Knows – Technically a Y.A. book with teen main characters, but fun for anyone who thinks ancient Egyptian artifacts and double crossing treasure seekers with family mysteries to solve sounds intriguing. It has an Indiana Jones vibe, for sure. There is a sequel I haven’t gotten into yet, but I would like to know what happens to the characters, so I probably will sometime. Perhaps the author describes the characters’ emotions a little too often and too fully, and there is a juvenile, headstrong and impulsive quality to the main characters that is overblown, but it is still a fairly riveting story. I love the title…3.25 stars. Content caution: language.
Emily Wilde’s Encyclopaedia of Faeries – This very popular book has a bit of a forced feel to some of the elements, but I really liked others. The creativity of the faerie world and the complexity of the two main characters kept me reading when it lagged at parts. What I didn’t like was the moral ambiguity between types of creatures. What is okay and what isn’t? Who is deciding? Who wants to do what is right and what isn’t and what are their reasons? As this is the first in the series, I’ll probably read the second book before giving up on the moral code of this particular world as a whole, but so far 3 stars. (Content caution: includes closed door romance, mild violence, some language – PG-13ish).
A Miss and An Almost


The Teller of Small Fortunes and The Spellshop both have beautiful covers and potentially refreshing settings and stories, but fell a bit flat for me. That being said, I think I will try the sequel to The Spellshop because there were several elements I liked, especially the setting. The slew of new creatures to keep track of and people groups and the flatness of a couple of the characters are what made it more of a “meh” for me, but I have to add that several of my friends really liked it, so maybe don’t just take my word for it! Content caution: Pretty mild overall for both of these, overall. Due to some romantic elements, high school and up, but I would also say there are some better options out there!
And that wraps up this catch-up post for fantasy reads of 2025-26! Come back for some much more wholehearted recommendations next time in the Children’s Fantasy department. Until then, happy reading!
























